Cinnamon Hummingbird

Welcome to the Birder's Diary Forum for Support And General Questions

Use the Support forum for all questions or issues.
Use the Wish List forum to leave your ideas for improving Birder’s Diary.
Setup your Forum photo, profile, and signature here.

Notifications
Clear all

[Solved] AviList

26 Posts
11 Users
3 Reactions
3,872 Views
Posts: 72
Topic starter
(@graham-tebb)
Trusted Member
Joined: 5 years ago
[#1936]

Dear Jeff,

Hope you're well and happy and enjoying life.  And hope you're going out to look at birds at least occasionally!

I'm sure I'm not the only one wondering about the future of the taxonomic lists now that AviList is supposed to solve all our problems.  I must confess to being no fan of the reordering of families and of species within the families but I suppose we'll have to work with it sooner or later.  What's your thinking on the taxonomic lists in BD?  Will there be an upgrade to the current IOC (and Clements) list to convert everything to AviList or will you continue to maintain the two separate versions until they finally align with each other and the rest of the world?  It's coming to that time of year again.

All the best,

Graham


Reply
25 Replies
Jeff
Posts: 1440
 Jeff
Admin
(@jeff)
Creator & Technical Support
Joined: 6 years ago

Hi Graham,

Thanks for posting this to the forums. I have been having several offline discussions on this topic with many BD users.

Both Cornell/Clements and the IOC World Bird Lists are claiming current, or soon, alignment with AviList. I think their wording can be rather vague on purpose; as the task is huge.

QUOTES FROM EACH:

Clements/Cornell: “The next annual revision… is expected to be in conjunction with the release of the WGAC/AviList Checklist, in the fall of 2025.”

IOC/IOU: "eBird/Clements and IOC have begun adopting WGAC decisions…”; "final draft will be completed by late 2024… made public in early 2025".

If the next (also claimed to possibly be the last) Clements release is "in conjunction" with AviList, then I see no reason for not shifting completely to AviList this October/November. If it is the same except for perhaps a name or two, a location in the hierarchy or two, a classification, etc. I cannot see where using one over the other will make any difference; even if you usually import/export from/to eBird and Birder's Diary. 

The Reconcile Wizard you all know and use each year will cleanly and efficiently assist you with moving your sightings from the older version of Clements or IOC into the new AviList taxonomy. I expect no difficulties there. In fact, with the dichotomy between attempting to align Clements with IOC that I do each year for the releases we completely eliminate that impossible task.

So, at this point, what I need are compelling reasons NOT to shift solely to AviList this Oct/Nov timeframe. By "compelling reasons", I mean something along the lines of...

"If I am using the eBird app on an upcoming trip to Indonesia, and all I have in BD is AviList instead of the Clements or IOC taxonomy, it will cause a problem for bird(s) x, y, and z; because [insert reason here]."

Or...

"If I have only AviList in BD, and attempt to export my sightings to an eBird import file, the import into eBird will cause problems for this bird, [insert name]. And explain the problem you foresee."

Give me a concrete use-case scenario where you envision a problem. At this point, I cannot foresee any.

So, let this be the place to have this discussion and see what we can find out.


Reply
(@aldeboro)
Joined: 6 years ago

Estimable Member
Posts: 139

@jeff 

The AOU (NACC) is not a party to the AviList committee. They are maintaining their own taxonomy and checklist. The ABA adhers to the AOU Taxonomy. Will you release the ABA and AOU checklists as well?

Al Borodayko


Reply
Jeff
 Jeff
Admin
(@jeff)
Joined: 6 years ago

Creator & Technical Support
Posts: 1440

@aldeboro 

Hi Al,

Yes, working on those. However, there were quality issues with the ABA's download, and errors. So I made the decision to go ahead and get the AviList out now and work on ABA and AOS afterwards. 

They are coming.


Reply
Jeff
 Jeff
Admin
(@jeff)
Joined: 6 years ago

Creator & Technical Support
Posts: 1440

@aldeboro 

Hi again Al. I was just checking the AviList.org website, and they sure list the AOS as one of their partners.

image

Reply
(@aldeboro)
Joined: 6 years ago

Estimable Member
Posts: 139

@jeff They are on the advisory board but remain independent.

See statement on Avilist site below:

NACC has been operating since 1883 and has internal processes for assessing proposals, and for voting and deciding on the taxonomy and nomenclature (including both scientific and English names) of North and Central American birds. Proposals and discussions are shared with AviList TaxCom, and the two operate in the spirit of maximizing consensus where possible, although their two taxonomies may not always be perfectly congruent. At the same time, NACC alone—among all regional advisory groups—is an independent external group not formally embedded with AviList and not subject to its executive decisions.

Al

 


Reply
Jeff
 Jeff
Admin
(@jeff)
Joined: 6 years ago

Creator & Technical Support
Posts: 1440

@aldeboro 

Gotcha. Thanks for clarifying Al.


Reply
Posts: 1
(@petethayer)
New Member
Joined: 1 year ago

Using the new AviList seems like the only logical move!

Make it so!!!


Reply
Jeff
Posts: 1440
 Jeff
Admin
(@jeff)
Creator & Technical Support
Joined: 6 years ago

Hello Jeff,

I totally support BD's proposed move to Avilist. I have already done it with an Excel list and found considerably more changes from both the most recent IOC and Clements list than I expected. There are major changes in sequencing and I lost more than 30 lifers from my IOC list.

If both IOC and Clements never update their most recent list, and they say they will not, Avilist is fundamentally the only choice.

Best regards,

Paul


Reply
Jeff
Posts: 1440
 Jeff
Admin
(@jeff)
Creator & Technical Support
Joined: 6 years ago

Hi Jeff,

Thanks for the link. I think the transition will actually be pretty easy. I've already downloaded the AviList 2025 excel file and gone through my 6,952 IOC 14.2 species with it. Four families lost, two families gained (and I've still seen at least one species in each family). 70 species lost by lumps, 2 species gained by splits that I have detected. There may be more, but I'll leave it to the reconcile wizard to find them rather than plowing through the zillions of subspecies I've seen! Whether eBird/Clements or IOC or AviList is "right," (there probably is no "right"), we now have will one taxonomy we can all use. I'm going to Australia in November. If  AviList for BD is available in time, I'll print out the AviList checklist and use it. If not, I'll use the IOC 14.2 and then let the reconcile wizard fix things up. Either way should work fine. I don't use eBird in the field, so there is no problem for me there.

John 


Reply
Posts: 72
Topic starter
(@graham-tebb)
Trusted Member
Joined: 5 years ago

Dear Jeff,

Thanks for this.  It sounds as though Clements/Cornell and the IOC will no longer be maintained, so if we want to keep up to date with taxonomic changes we have no choice but to switch.  It should save you a lot of work each year!

I have had a quick look at the AviList and am not thrilled.  Some of the decisions on lumps and splits seem premature (take a look at Granatellus, for example - see the reasoned discussion on the SACC for background) and it will take a while for us to grow used to the new order of families and of genera within each family.  Each new taxonomy is prefaced by a statement from the perpetrators to the effect that they don't like change any more than the rest of us but their version is right and they are sure it will become the standard in the future.  If I had a dollar for every time I have read that ...

There should be no problem exporting records to eBird even before the reconciliation is complete. I use IOC (14.2) and have recently started exporting some old sightings to eBird.  The import routine asks me to identify species (nearly all my records are at the subspecies level) and this takes a while but is not particularly problematic.  The most difficult part is checking the gps coordinates of my locations on google maps - the taxonomic issues have been minor (my eBird "world" list is now over 5,500, so only about 3,000 or so species to go:  I'm far enough into the process to have encountered any systematic problems there may be).

It sounds as though BD will switch completely to AviList from the next update (apart from those who will stick to the AOU list, which I assume will be a subset of AviList).  As others have said before me, that seems like a very sensible decision and "the only way to go".  I look forward to it!

All the best,

Graham


Reply
Jeff
Posts: 1440
 Jeff
Admin
(@jeff)
Creator & Technical Support
Joined: 6 years ago

Move on to the AviList.  I have not tried it but combining the world list has to be a step forward even if imperfect.  We should expect mistakes and things that can be improved.

The commenters on AviList are the serious listers making my 2,742 look puny.  I am surprised they lost species: I expected gains.  In any case AviList is the future for now, but like most major changes on any subject, we will have to work through a period of imperfection.

Allan


Reply
Posts: 1
(@roaminoz)
New Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Me too Jeff ... Australia's BirdLife is taking on the AviList and I have already changed my BD to the AviList ..  massive change in sequence of order and having to learn all over again.

Jude


Reply
Posts: 72
Topic starter
(@graham-tebb)
Trusted Member
Joined: 5 years ago

Dear Allan,

It may depend on where you've seen most of your species (and 2,742 is a serious number).  Compared with the IOC list, which most of us seem to use (because it contains more species than Clements/Cornell so our numbers are higher), there are a good number of lumps in S America and SE Asia, particularly Indonesia.  I think I'll be down by 40 or so when I make the change.  But I'll have far fewer species left to chase, which will be a serious plus!  I only wish that the order of families and species was closer to the one we know.

All the best,

Graham


Reply
Posts: 9
(@rlsiebert)
Active Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Jeff,

I think AviList is a great move forward. It is long overdue that we get rid of the question "Do I have more lifers this year on IOC or Clements?". I hope gaining this single list will help field researchers get their data accepted so that we really know what species are out there.

I have been using eBird in the field since it got started. Since I have an iPhone I cannot switch to Birder's Diary mobile. Import from eBird to BD is now very simple and I truly appreciate the improvements that were made over time.

I have never used IOC, only Clements, especially after eBird became linked to it.

My only concern with BD moving to AviList would be if the import from eBird became broken. Perhaps a delay could occur as eBird moves to AviList. I certainly hope that Cornell will not release a taxonomy update that is used by eBird but is not AviList. 

If it did happen I would have to stop importing from eBird until things got resolved. I would not want to buy another "short-term" update to Clements and also buy AviList and not be able to use it.

I look forward to getting my data into AviList. I expect minor changes in my lifer total (a bit over 5000).

Randy

 


Reply
Jeff
 Jeff
Admin
(@jeff)
Joined: 6 years ago

Creator & Technical Support
Posts: 1440

@rlsiebert 

Hi Randy,

I cannot foresee any way in which any tax list would have a problem going to/from eBird import/export. Especially one that is fairly aligned with eBird. There are too many checks & safe-guards both ways to catch problems.

Thanks for the note.


Reply
Posts: 1
(@tbird)
New Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Jeff - Do the right thing!  Do Avilist.  The conservation rationale is a good one.  Although some species have been lumped, I suspect that this will encourage more research to re-establish them.  Others perhaps deserve to be lumped.  Is there really a specific difference between Australasia and Black-backed Swamphens?  One problem not yet addressed is when and how updates will be done on Avilist.  Some organizations may not be buying in.  For example, AOU's 2025 update split both warbling vireo and nutting's flycatcher, neither of which are in Avilist.  On the other hand, the split of squirrel cuckoo and white-throated thrush are both incorporated in Avilist.   


Reply
Posts: 1
(@toucanet)
New Member
Joined: 1 year ago

Hi Jeff, please go ahead with changing to AviList this fall. Finally ONE list! Let's accept the split/ lump compromises that come with the benefits of global bird list harmonization. Regards, Jörg


Reply
Page 1 / 2
Share: